Monthly Accounting that founders are proud to use.

Choosing an entity is as much about future plans as it is about taxes today. A single‑member LLC is flexible and simple to start; by default it is disregarded for federal tax and flows to your personal return, which keeps early compliance light. A multi‑member LLC is taxed as a partnership, which allows for special allocations and flexible capital structures, but it introduces a partnership return and K‑1s. An S‑Corporation is not a type of company you form but a tax election for an eligible corporation or LLC. It can reduce self‑employment taxes once there is consistent profit because owners pay themselves a W‑2 salary that is subject to payroll tax and then take the rest as distributions that are generally not. The S‑Corp does require reasonable compensation, payroll, and tighter bookkeeping. A C‑Corporation is the default for venture‑scale companies because preferred stock, option pools, and QSBS eligibility are cleaner, and investors often require it. A C‑Corp pays its own tax at the corporate rate and you pay again if the company distributes cash, but many startups reinvest for years and plan for stock exits. If you are raising institutional money, want to qualify for potential Section 1202 QSBS treatment, or expect to scale nationally, a Delaware C‑Corp can make sense. If you are bootstrapping services and care about current year tax efficiency and simplicity, an LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship or S‑Corp may fit better. The right answer depends on profit timing, hiring plans, expected investors, and your appetite for compliance.

If you decide an S‑Corporation is right, you make the election by filing Form 2553 with the IRS. The general deadline is two months and fifteen days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect. Many founders start as an LLC or corporation and then elect S status when profits are stable enough to justify payroll and the administrative overhead. If you miss the deadline, late election relief is often available when the intent to be an S‑Corp was clear and the failure was due to reasonable cause. The election requires that shareholders be eligible persons, that there be only one class of stock, and that you stay within the shareholder limits. Once effective, the company files an S‑Corporation return and issues K‑1s, and owner‑operators must be on W‑2 payroll at a reasonable salary. Health insurance for more‑than‑two‑percent shareholders is included in wages for income tax purposes, and while the specifics can be technical, the aim is to capture the right amounts on the W‑2 while handling payroll taxes appropriately. Because the S‑Corp can reduce exposure to self‑employment tax when structured correctly, the IRS expects payroll that reflects your role and market conditions. If your profits are inconsistent or minimal, the costs of payroll and compliance may outweigh the benefit, and you can wait. If you are converting mid‑year, coordinate the timing so state accounts, payroll systems, and bookkeeping all align with the election date for a clean start.

The tax law distinguishes between startup costs and organizational costs, and both are treated differently from ordinary expenses. Startup costs are the amounts you pay before the business actually begins, such as researching the market, creating a business plan, training, or trial advertising. Organizational costs relate directly to forming the entity, like state filing fees, legal fees for drafting the charter and bylaws, and costs of organizational meetings. The rules allow a limited amount to be deducted immediately in the first year the business is active, with the remainder amortized over a set period. There is also a phaseout as total costs increase beyond certain thresholds, which means very large pre‑opening projects are more likely to be amortized than expensed up front. Practically, founders should track pre‑opening spending separately, document the date “active trade or business” begins, and be ready to support the amounts and categories. If you paid costs personally before formation, you can contribute them to the company or have the company reimburse you under an accountable plan so the deduction lives where the income will live. Getting this right matters because it affects your first return and sets the baseline for depreciation and amortization schedules going forward. Good records, a clear start date, and a simple roll‑forward of unamortized balances will save time at every year‑end close and during any due diligence process.

The United States tax system expects you to pay as you go, which means founders with pass‑through income or salary must make timely payments during the year. If you are operating as a sole proprietor or a partner in an LLC taxed as a partnership, your share of business profit is generally subject to both income tax and self‑employment tax. You may need to make four estimated payments using vouchers for federal and state, and you may have city estimates as well. Safe harbors exist to avoid penalties, but they reference either last year’s tax or a percentage of current year income, so they are less helpful in a first year with no prior history. A practical approach is to project profit quarterly, include the impact of self‑employment tax or payroll, and adjust estimates as your revenue stabilizes. If you transition to an S‑Corporation, your W‑2 withholding can carry much of the burden, but you still may need estimates for the K‑1 portion. Founders with multiple income sources—consulting, equity comp, interest, and the business—often benefit from an “annualized income” method to match payments to seasonality. The key is to separate cash kept aside for taxes from operating cash so payroll and vendor payments are never at risk. Keep in mind that some states require separate payments for franchise or gross receipts taxes that are not tied to income, and first‑time founders are often surprised by those bills. Building taxes into your runway is as important as budgeting for software or headcount.

Reasonable compensation is the salary an S‑Corporation pays to a shareholder‑employee for the services they actually perform. The IRS expects that owner‑operators on S‑Corp payroll receive a market‑based wage before taking distributions. The concept matters because wages are subject to payroll taxes while distributions generally are not, and paying zero or artificially low salary to avoid employment taxes invites scrutiny. Determining a reasonable number is not a formula; it is a facts‑and‑circumstances analysis. You consider your role, hours, duties, revenue and profit levels, the compensation of comparable positions in your market, and what the company could afford to pay a non‑owner to do the same work. Early in the life of a startup, the salary may be modest and increase as the business stabilizes, but it should still reflect the reality of services provided. Documenting the analysis is wise, especially if distributions become significant. Health insurance for more‑than‑two‑percent owners and certain fringe benefits have special treatment in the payroll system, and handling them correctly keeps your W‑2 clean. The goal is to pick a number that is defensible to an auditor, affordable for the company, and consistent with compensation paid to people in similar roles. Done right, reasonable compensation supports both compliance and tax efficiency rather than being a guess at year end.